Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Duncan Shields

Duncan is the Creative Director at Redengine SCC in Australia.

In this long-standing feature, Branding in Asia reaches out to experts in the ad world to get their input on ads they like and those that they are not so crazy about.

This week Duncan Shields, Creative Director at Sydney-based Redengine SCC chimes in with his two picks and a pan.


One I Like

“We All Win” – Microsoft

Why I like it: It captures so much life.

Using ‘real’ people in ads is not easy, getting an emotional story arc from a whole group of them is even harder. And don’t let the ‘underproduced’ style fool you – lo-fi shooting doesn’t automatically add authenticity, like Google Pixel 3 – Group Selfie Cam for example.  Authenticity comes from great direction and editing – hats off.

A Pleasure to Follow – Audi

Why I like it: I absolutely love ads that offer as much entertainment factor as the content they interrupt and this is a great example of doing just that. This ad oozes craft at every turn (excuse the pun).

From the overall look to the great choice in music, all the way down to the performances of each of the characters (the perp on the backseat is my favorite). Even the most weathered and cynical creatives would find it hard not to smile at the silliness of the situation when the reveal comes around at the end. It’s a good, old-fashioned entertaining ad that displays huge amounts of skill and craftsmanship. More of these, please.

One I like less than the others (quite a lot less)

Change Up the Usual – Stella Artois

Perhaps an obvious choice but one that bothered me so much, I haven’t been able to shake it from my memory. You guessed it, it’s the Stella Artois Superbowl ad with Carrie Bradshaw and the Dude:

I think the thing that bothers me most about that ad is that it’s a Stella Artois ad. It now sits alongside some of the best beer ads ever made and quite frankly, it doesn’t stack up at all.

Stella ads used to be right at the pinnacle of creative storytelling – hell, I got into advertising dreaming of making ads like Stella used to.

Ads like this:

And this:

And I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the production of both of these ads combined cost less than Carrie’s Cosmopolitan… sorry, Stella Artois.

Duncan Shields
Duncan Shields
Duncan is the Creative Director at Redengine SCC in Australia.

Want to submit your own take on three ads?
staff@brandinginasia.com

Branding in Asia Newsletter

We don't share your info. We only share ours.

Two Ads I Like And One I Don’t – Lauren Pomphrey

Brands and agencies tend to shy away from “purpose”, feeling it safer to stick to their remit of simply making ads. But occasionally, a brand has a real chance to own a space and do more than just advertise.

Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Yasushi Ogata

There are many well-made Japanese style campaigns which feature someone famous, but I personally don’t gravitate towards TVCs focused just around a celebrity.

Two Ads I Like And One I Don’t – Alyson Ho

As communication technology powers ahead towards faster data speeds and wider connectivity, perhaps it’s no longer about portraying technology as something that enables us to do more, but technology as a window from which we experience the world – opening up many more possibilities.

Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Anthony Moss

The average consumer doesn’t hunt out ads to see more of them, in fact they try their best to block, avoid or ignore them.

Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Duncan Shields

Using ‘real’ people in ads is not easy, getting an emotional story arc from a whole group of them is even harder. And don’t let the ‘underproduced’ style fool you.

Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Niniek Sugiarti

I love watching Superbowl ads because this is when and where all the entertaining and big-budget ads are aired in one large burst. For this year’s Superbowl, I especially enjoyed the Amazon Alexa ad “Not everything makes the cut”.

Two Ads I Like and One I Don’t – Joaquim Laurel

It is not easy to do funny well, and a lot of times we fall into the trap of setting up gags versus finding funny truths.

The Latest

Interview: Arpan Jain on Creative Campaign Trends in India’s Diverse Market and More

Being committed to inspiring action through behavior and experience-led ideas, we’re constantly trying to move away from the idea of ‘sheep dipping’ people in a brand, and instead, focusing on creating behavioral change.

Red Bull Documentary Charts the Journey of ‘Machina’ from K-Pop to Techno Artist In Tokyo

"Machina" paints a less than flattering portrait of her time in South Korea's KPop industry, saying it made her feel like a "doll" and was "just a business".

Asia’s Top YouTube Ads for March 2019

In March, viewers across APAC loved watching ads that combined two seemingly unrelated ideas to create a unique story.

BBDO Atlanta Chief Creative Officer Robin Fitzgerald Named Ad Stars Executive Judge

Ad Stars has announced that Robin Fitzgerald, Chief Creative Officer at BBDO Atlanta, is joining Ad Stars 2019 as an Executive Judge.

Cheil Worldwide Appoints Ricardo Catalano as COO in France

The appointment will allow the network to strengthen its data-driven marketing capabilities.

Interviews

Interview: Arpan Jain on Creative Campaign Trends in India’s Diverse Market and More

Being committed to inspiring action through behavior and experience-led ideas, we’re constantly trying to move away from the idea of ‘sheep dipping’ people in a brand, and instead, focusing on creating behavioral change.

Q&A: Malcolm Koh – ‘The Customer Experience Gap is Widening Across APAC’

We already know organizations are constantly trying to catch up with customers’ expectations, but I was most surprised to see just how fast the customer experience gap is widening across APAC.

Kemp CMO Tony Thompson on Marketing Application Delivery

The global CMO of Kemp shares how product positioning changed in light of technological innovations, and how he markets the product through partners.

Q&A: Gary Steele – ‘You Don’t Have to Always Try to Break the Rules’

We have achieved our goal within two years here at TBWA\Singapore. Now we need to set our sights on something much bigger than Southeast Asia. This means picking up Agency of the Year in Cannes.

One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight

One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight – Darren Chia, Geometry Malaysia

Branding in Asia brings you “One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight”, a feature focusing on up-and-coming individuals in the ad world. Darren Chia, Geometry Malaysia.

One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight – Adith Fernandes, FCB Interface

Branding in Asia brings you “One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight”, a feature focusing on up-and-coming individuals in the ad world.Next up is Adith Fernandes, senior copywriter at FCB Interface.

One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight – Gavin Lee, Digitas China

Gavin Lee eventually went on to work with Blak Labs, Dentsu and the back to Saatchi & Saatchi in China before settling in with Digitas in Shanghai in August of last year.

One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight – Victor Aldabalde, Lion & Lion


As part of an ongoing series highlighting young talent in the industry, Branding in Asia brings you “One Under 30: Young Creative Spotlight”, a feature focusing on up-and-coming individuals in the ad world.